Black information Link:

home campaigns act now policy & research press releases links subscribe contact us

black information link The 1990 Trust, human rights for race equality
The 1990 Trust's independent community website for black communities

2007 Bicentenary of Abolition
America at war
Armed Forces
Black Elders
Black Workers
Blink Interview
Civil Liberties
Crime & Policing
Human Rights
News Digest
Northern Ireland
Rural racism
Society & Environment
Stephen Lawrence
The 1990 Trust
UK regions

Sweet-talk fails to save Michael Howard from pasting

By Lester Holloway

A DESPERATE damage-limitation exercise by Conservative leader Michael Howard, following last week’s stop and search speech, failed to save him from a pasting in today’s Black media.

Michael Howard keeps an eye on the Black and Asian media
Michael Howard keeps an eye on the Black and Asian media

Howard was blasted by race campaigners last week, including Karen Chouhan chief executive of The 1990 Trust, after the Tory leader claimed he would ditch any plans for police officers to monitor street stops by ethnicity.

The public inquiry into the death of Stephen Lawrence recommended that such monitoring was necessary to identify patterns of race discrimination, and Howard’s comments were interpreted as “disrespecting the legacy of Lawrence.”

In the speech on Tuesday, delivered in Middlesborough where ‘Robocop’ Ray Mallon was elected mayor on a zero-tolerance platform, Howard described as 'politically correct' proposals to monitor police stops on race in order to detect racially discriminatory patterns of behaviour.

In a statement to Blink, Howard said: “We will not implement the recommendation in the McPherson Report that the police keep a record of every stop they make, but the police should, of course, continue to keep records of anyone they stop and search.”

Then just a day later, Howard said teachers should be left alone to exclude as many unruly pupils as they wish without interference from the state. African-Caribbean children already four times more likely to be excluded, and a growing proportion of Muslim children also being expelled.


Howard has spent the last year trying to court Black and Asian voters, including selecting a record number of minority ethnic candidates to fight the next general election and embarking on a series of diversity speeches.

Sensing a backlash against his comments, Howard mounted a rearguard action to woo the Black and Asian media. But this failed to save the Tory leader from a savaging, with The Voice, New Nation and the Asian Times laying into him.

 - quote - Howard's efforts have been undermined by his silly mistake. If he wants the Black vote he should talk to us first  - unquote -
Karen Chouhan – The 1990 Trust

Howard made an impromptu visit to The Voice offices in Brixton, to claim he had been misunderstood. He said: “There was a lot of misunderstanding of what I was saying. I was not talking about stop and search.

“Every time they stop someone it takes an average of seven minutes to fill out a record. If the police have to take seven minutes to fill out a form they are going to think twice before stopping someone.”

But this failed to impress. The paper’s editorial said: “The Tories’ retrograde thinking on the issue has undermined all the efforts liberal-minded members of his party have made to court the black vote.”

And the New Nation editorial said: “Last week the friendly, inclusive façade they have so carefully erected came crashing down as their leader went back to his roots and announced that if he came to power he would support more stop and search and that ethnic monitoring of the policy would be consigned to the history books.”

Your Shout!

Who is the real Michael Howard – the hardline former Home Secretary or the new multicultural one? Have your say here

Karen Chouhan of The 1990 Trust said: “The efforts Howard has been making have all been undermined by his silly mistake. If he wants the Black vote, before he makes statements like this again he needs to come and talk to us first. That way, he will realise the impact such words will have on Black communities.

“It seems inevitable that his comments would provoke the reaction it did. We are pleased that he is now confirming that he is not talking about abandoning race monitoring of stops and searches.”

But Len Duvall, chair of the Metropolitan Police Authority, said that recommendation 61 of the Lawrence report was “not about political correctness.”

He said: “The issue should not be mistakenly associated with political correctness – it is about regaining the trust and confidence of all our communities.

“Young Londoners of all backgrounds told the MPA during our recent Stop & Search Scrutiny that they are worried by current practice which, in their eyes, appears unaccountable and hostile.”


Since becoming leader last year Howard had gone further than any previous Tory leader in making a full scale bid for the Black and Asian vote. Shedding his hardman image, cultivated as Home Secretary between 1993 and 1997, Howard has been regularly seen at minority ethnic events.

Michael Howard attacking the BNP in Burnley earlier this year
Michael Howard attacking the BNP in Burnley earlier this year

In February Howard launched a stinging attack on the British National Party during a keynote address in Oldham.

And under his leadership the Tories have selected a number of minority ethnic candidates to fight the next general election, including Adam Afriyie in the safe Tory seat of Windsor, and Shailesh Vara in North West Cambridgeshire, which is also seen as a true blue seat.

Howard has recently suffered from poor poll ratings and growing disquiet on his own benches that he was not capitalising on the governments’ difficulties. Howard recently admitted he had ‘a long way to go’ to overturn Labour’s majority at the election.

But Howards' supporters claim he remains committed to winning the Black vote.

Send to a friend
Send to a friend
print document
Print document

Local Government
David Cameron

Related Stories

Give Tory associations race training David Cameron still has much to prove on race Tory asylum row – are they racist? You decide. Tories defend immigration policies after backlash Give us clarification not chaos! Calm down dears… its only an election Shame on you, Mr Howard A Tribute to Malcolm X thru' Hip-Hop, Rap and Spoken-word Poetry William Hague slapped down over slavery gaff Sweet-talk fails to save Michael Howard from pasting Black is the new Blue for Tories Michael Howard says he’s an ethnic minority Tory gains on race could be reversed by Davis David Davis supported ” racist colleague ” now he must prove he’s changed Millions for Reparations Rally in Washington


Speech by Valerie Amos, Leader of the House of Lords

Tony Blair speech to Labour conference 2006

Black Representation in Government

pdf At a turning point? The State of Race relations in Kingston upon Hull

JCWI'S Top 10 Recommendations

List of MPs who voted for and against the war in Iraq

Transcript of BNP Mayoral candidate interviewed on BBC London Radio's John Gaunt show

pdf BNP candidates and constituencies 2004


Pluto Press

Pluto Press

The Power Inquiry

Unite Against Fascism


Stop the BNP

BNP: Under the skin

Research community network: Stopping hate and building safer communities

Operation Black Vote

UNITE TO PROTECT OUR RIGHTS: sign the statement against the erosion of civil liberties and human rights by new anti-terrorism proposals A Black Manifesto No 2 ID FREE FAROUQ PDP ASSOCIATES Power to the People

Published by The 1990 Trust

This website is subject to a disclaimer: Please read

Black Information Link. All rights reserved.

Suite 12 Winchester House 
9 Cranmer Road
London SW9 6EJ
Tel: 020  7582 1990
Fax: 020 7793 8269

top of pagetop of page

powered by Linux